Kenosis and the nature of the persons in the trinity semantic scholar. If jesus was not fully divine, then his atoning work would not be sufficient to atone for the sins of the world. For example, how could an all knowing god become a baby, or how could god be tempted. However, others contend that this verb simply presenting to us the condescension of our lord. Professor oord, as i said in my initial response, i saw a few issues with some of the arguments made in the article posted on biologos and, i suppose, the theory of essential. Prevailing secularization theory suggests that this is an irrelevant question. He set himself the task of suggesting another theory which, while escaping the errors of kenoticism, would do full justice to the humanity of christ. Robertson, louis berkhof and other scholars strongly denied the kenosis theory. A god whose essential nature is kenosis love and that interacts with creatures who are essentially free would not be culpable for failing to prevent genuine evils.
Embracing by johann jakob herzog, philip schaff, albert hauck 1910 scrip 68 where paul says that christ tu ral being in the form of god, thought it basis of not robbery to be equal with god, but kenosis. Some have postulated a kenotic theory on a biblical basis. Fortress, 1991, both interpret divine kenosis as an assertion about. I therefore describe my proposal as a binding kenosis as, although voluntarily entered by god, it involves a degree of necessity upon god while the present world order continues. The correct doctrine is the hypostatic unionthat jesus is both fully god and fully man col. The term kenosis refers to the doctrine of christs selfemptying in his incarnation. Their chief contribution to a biblical christology was a determined insistence upon both the humanity and deity of our lord, and also a refusal to. Late greek kenosis, from greek, an emptying, from kenoun, to empty, from kenos, empty.
In christian theology, kenosis is the selfemptying of jesus own will and becoming entirely. Father kevin cronin, a franciscan priest, tells of his work among the poor and homeless of new york city. One of the great mysteries contained in the bible is that it teaches that jesus is fully god and also that he is fully man. Who, although he existed in the form of god, did not regard equality with god a thing to be grasped, but emptied himself, taking the form of a bondservant, and being made in the likeness of men. Yoder, in examining what could be gleaned regarding how jesus functioned in the application of politics, used the term radical subordination to explain the concept of kenosis.
Mcclain the doctrine of the kenosis in philippians 2. Did the baby in the manger know that the world was round. Warfield condemned as a mistranslation in this context. Miller, dbt skills manual for adolescents new york. Each of these four themes is important in the development of my.
Kenosis only makes sense or we have to make it make sense in the context of a larger system of concepts and interpretations, and current discussions of kenosis involve philosophy of science, sociology and anthropology, systems theory, and information theory in addition to traditional theology, adding complexity to the. Pdf kenosis and the nature of the persons in the trinity. The verb translated made of no reputation is ekenosen. You cannot be god if you do not possess attributes of divinity. This is called the kenotic doctrine, and according to it, they imagine that the divinity was taken away from the word in christ. Not of necessity, but out of the sovereign choice of love, he gave up heavens glory for the way of the cross. As a christological statement it has been appealed to as a scriptural warrant for a highly distinctive understanding of the incarnation. The kenosis is a teaching concerning jesus incarnation. He stooped to servanthood and death with all the sovereign free will of one whose choices are limited only by his own holy and loving will. The term keno s i s comes from the greek verb kenoo, used in phil. Please, subscribe or login to access full text content. The kenosis theory holds that christ gave up some of his divine attributes while he was on earth as a man. Pinnock, 2001 has stressed human free will, but their belief in gods limitation has incurred the wrath of many calvinists. The kenotic theory was popular in germany between about 1860.
Pdf christs kenosis in christianity from a perspective of sunyata. But the free obedience of our lord jesus christ rises above all human. One theory which received widespread emphasis and acceptance in the late nineteenth century and whose influence is still felt today is the socalled kenotic theory of the person of christ. A brief history of the kenosis theory the heidelblog. This is the realm of life like god, free from causal relations, where one is the. The kenotic kenosis doctrine is heresy petri paavola. Dorner was one of the first and the greatest of the opponents of the kenosis doctrine. The kenosis maintains that god, when becoming a man, divested himself of some qualities of being a man. Kenotic theology at the theoretical level is a way of conceiving of the. The kenosis theory states that jesus gave up some of his divine attributes while he was a man here on earth. The kenosis attempts to solve some paradoxes between the nature of god and of man as united in jesus. In the nineteenth century, the rise of new scientific theories, including the biological.
Did jesus empty his divine attributes and leave heaven. While individuals are free to close themselves off. Below you will find example usage of this term as found in modern andor classical literature. Theologians have used the major part of that verb to form the term kenosis.
One of the most controversial subjects concerning the person of our lord is the kenosis of christ. Speaking of both christs divinity and humanity, the apostle john writes, in the beginning was the word, and the word was with. When used of christ, the noun signifies the union of his two natures, the. This was the era of the modern kenotic theories, during which, as might be expected. Christ did this voluntarily so that he could function as a man in order to fulfill the work of redemption.
The holders of the theory would logically have to answer. This new view was called the kenosis theory, and the overall position it represented was called kenotic theology. Kenosis definition, the doctrine that christ relinquished his divine attributes so as to experience human suffering. This greek term is formed from a reflexive verb meaning he emptied himself phil. The new schaffherzog encyclopedia of religious knowledge. It is high and heavenly doctrine and for that reason of little appeal to dull minds and darkened hearts. The doctrine of kenosis attempts to explain what the son of god jesus christ. Christianity the relinquishment of some of the attributes of god by jesus in becoming man and suffering death. When we study the bible, we see that the aforesaid thing is not true. It is concerned with an emphasis on christs humiliation or condescension. Kenosis and the nature of the persons in the trinity philippians 2.
Kenosis doctrine is heresy general discussion worthy. Posted in attention, book summary, books, cognitive science, education, emotions, flow, membersonly, personal growth. Subscribe to my free weekly newsletter and get my best tips on how to. In christianity, there exists a socalled kenotic doctrine kenosis. It has been accepted for inclusion in dissertations by an authorized administrator of loyola ecommons. A perspective from regress 9 theory traced in the thought of. Kenosis definition of kenosis by the free dictionary. In the first part of the 19th century, when ferdinand baur became professor of theology at germanys tubingen university, he following in the footsteps of g. Some people who uphold the kenosis doctrine say that when jesus said the son can do nothing of himself, so it is the proof that the kenosis doctrine is biblical and correct. Henry calls this theory the fourth great attempt at a theological explanation of christs being.
Look up kenosis in wiktionary, the free dictionary. He who has knowledge of the truth is a free man, but the free man does not sin, for he who sins is the slave of sin. Hegel began in earnest to attack the historical credibility of the. The term kenosis comes from the greek word kenoo, translated emptied in chapter 2 of pauls letter to the philippians. The doctrine argues that jesus gave up some of his divine characteristics when he was on earth in the flesh. These attributes were omniscience, omnipresence, and omnipotence. Kenosis theory attempts to answer this mystery in an inadequate manner. If this alternative conception of kenosis were to be adopted, the conceptual framework would be in place for essayists to view consistently gods actions as the work of love. A principle of divine kenosis or condescension in some sense lies at the heart of any incarnational christology. The kenosis theory is a dangerous doctrine because if it were true, then it would mean that jesus was not fully divine.
Following the example of christ who though he was in the form of god he did not deem. I like mystery over paradox because paradox may mean either a statement that seems contradictory but in fact may be true or a statement that is selfcontradictory and therefore is false. I accidentally held to it for a little while but now deny it. The book also explores the implications of a kenotic view of the incarnation for philosophical theology in general and the doctrine of the trinity in particular, and it concludes with essays that examine the validity of the ideal of kenosis for women, and a challenge to traditional christology to.
Kenosis and the nature of the persons in the trinity. Divine suffering in history and theology minneapolis. Others have sought to understand kenosis predominantly from a philosophical approach, with the two natures of christ as a starting point. A biblical and theological answer to the false doctrine of kenosis introduction an increasingly prevalent teaching in evangelical circles, particularly in charismatic circles, is the doctrine of kenosis. While the term is found in a number of patristic writers and formed a key point of controversy. The presupposition of the theory is that the distinctive divine attributes of omnipotence, omniscience and omnipresence etc. This false teaching is drawn from impure wells, it is dangerous because of the other false doctrines it leads to, and it flies in the face of the heart of christian teaching. Kenosis and the biblical picture of the world american scientific. Gottfried thomasius view of kenotic christology religion essay. The use of emptied reflects the views of a school of thought that developed in the mid19th century. A young dedicated idealist, he soon discovered the hidden seed of true christian kenosis, the greek term for emptying ones self, so that the grace and presence of god may come in and work its will. He now is subject to the whim of time and circumstance yoder, 1994. With regard to christ, there is a kenosis of the son of god, a condescension and selfsacrifice for the redemption and salvation of all humanity. I will also examine the harm that the kenosis theory has caused to churches in the.
1027 892 514 863 1319 250 581 538 1351 489 659 1533 1084 1181 888 498 1447 654 1053 931 1238 283 433 447 1235 378 112 454 796 1554 1572 1303 10 894 1058 159 1616 699 1280 457 780 1453 1086 1079 1337 743 1046 88 1349